Specialist Tyrol continues to sink into despair after his recent loss. He becomes curious about Gaius Baltar’s sermons and the following he has attracted. The crew of the Demetrius grow concerned about Kara’s mental stability as an old enemy arrives with a tempting offer.
When Earl finally wakes up from his coma, he believes in Karma again and considers Billie his soul mate.
Barney and Marshall have a discussion about “The Bro Code” because Barney has broken it and wants advice.
Gaius Baltar sets off a debate on religious freedom when he promotes his belief in a single God.
When the hospital wants to get rid of Earl, Randy decides to take care of his brother by himself. But instead of working on the list for Earl, he uses Earl’s help to cross things off in order to help him get better.
Robin’s musical past emerges again as the group learns of someone named Simon from Robin’s past. Barney searches for more Robin Sparkles memorabilia.
Kara Thrace seeks her own path in the search for Earth while the Cylons face the threat of sentient Centurions. A member of Galactica’s crew learns a dark secret about a loved one.
When Randy visits his parents to make up for their ruined vacation, he realizes that he forgot to tell them about Earl’s prison sentence and the following coma at all.
A flashback takes us back to when Earl and Randy ruined their parents vacation due to a stolen duffel bag full of weed.
After Marshall witnesses a work buddy get yelled at after handing in a report, he becomes paranoid that the same will happen to him.
The Cylons learn that the Final Five are in the Colonial fleet. Some of the Cylons want the Cavil model to stop lobotomizing the Raider ships. Starbuck desperately tries to convince the others that the fleet is going the wrong way in their search for Earth.